> FTF
Family Tree Forum
> loftily referred to previous answers
Know what you mean. I posted a look-up request on the Worcs board at RC and some "helpful" person replied that the information would be available in the PRs at the Worcs CRO. Doh!
> I have no real clue what a records office contains ...
Well, amongst heaps of other stuff, they've got the PRs on microfiche which is brill if you know the exact parish, but not quite so brill if you only know that it was, e.g. Barnsley, because Barnsley could be made up of a dozen or more parishes. If it's a date post-census (i.e. after 1841), then the census can help with the parish, so if they were living in, say, St Luke's parish, Barnsley in 1851, 1861 and 1871, then if I was looking for them pre-1841 I'd start with St Luke's PRs, and if they weren't there, I'd work out from St Luke's to adjoining parishes. Pity your folk weren't village people (like mine). Only one parish church per village = only one place to look. If not there, try next village etc.
The earlier the records get, the less regular they are, so you're more dependent on the rector/vicar/curate as to how much information they give. If you're not that familiar with what earlier PRs look like, if you PM me your email address, I'll send you some examples. [Edited to say: If that last bit sounds patronising, it's not meant to.]
> I want to know how people get so far back with any certainty .... 1790s.
Well, it's a mute point about how certain they can be, without seeing their "evidence". They could have assumed that the John Smith who married Mary Jones were their John and Mary, or there might have been something in the PRs that leads naturally to that conclusion. The "problem" with your Hinchliffes, as I see it is that there are (a) a lot of them, so you'd need to track all of them to see if you could work out who's who/who's married to who etc and (b) they could well be recorded as Hinchcliffe or other variations.
> My one stuck ... George
Personally, if he wasn't in my direct line, but "merely" someone's brother, I'd settle for not knowing, but appreciate that not everyone take the same stance.
Not at all sure that my ramblings are helping.
STG